Second (popular) version only 1845. For Violin and Piano reduction of both the earlier 1844 and the later popular version 1845 see BA9050-92.
In 1838 Felix Mendelssohn wrote to the Violin virtuoso Ferdinand David informing him that he was working on a Violin concerto “… the opening theme, one in E minor runs through my head and it gives me no peace”; the concerto in the state described by Mendelssohn to David was never published in a performing edition – it was only rediscovered in 1988.
One would think that such an important work would be adequately represented in modern editions true to the sources. Alas not even the score used today represents the orchestral parts Mendelssohn saw to print in 1845, but one heavily edited in the 1860s by Julius Rietz for the Mendelssohn Complete Edition.
For the Bärenreiter Urtext edition, the Mendelssohn specialist R. Larry Todd has edited both the original version of the concerto as well as the later version more popular today.
The first version of the concerto calls for the soloist to perform the orchestral tuttis, contains a shorter cadenza by Mendelssohn, many solo Violin pitches in different octaves, passages with different orchestral scoring and many many surprises regarding articulation and dynamics.
The later (popular) version goes back to the first edition orchestral parts published in 1845 and the Piano reduction sanctioned by Mendelssohn.
Todd makes use of all known sources including the letters between Mendelssohn and David as well as Mendelssohn and the original publishers where general schemes as well as specifics of articulation were exchanged.
This first ever Urtext edition of one of the most well-known Violin concertos in the repertoire finally gives performers the opportunity of playing just what Mendelssohn wrote.
The Bärenreiter Urtext edition offers the two versions of Op.64 back to back in score and parts together with facsimiles, an informative preface describing the genesis of the composition and a detailed critical commentary.
First ever Urtext edition of both versions of Op.64.
Critical Commentary (Engl.) included with full score.
Informative preface (Engl. / Ger.).
Piano reductions each with an Urtext Violin part and a second Violin part prepared with fingerings and bowings.