Nice to have all these sonatas in one place, however I'm not entirely convinced by this edition. Some fingerings I find questionable (e.g. in D.784, last movement, using the same finger for consecutive notes in order to start a new phrase -- necessary?); also, some pedal markings are inconsistently placed, and also generally rather dubious (e.g. whole first bar pedalled in D.784). Binding is not the best, either -- (e.g.) Henle Urtext seems much more sturdy. Only had this a week, and already some pages look set to fall out. However, it's well printed, and a bit of work with a soft pencil can help a lot!
- (Oban, United Kingdom)